Shop Mobile More Submit  Join Login
About Deviant Community Volunteer Joseph Louis Gay-LussacUnknown Groups :iconthewrittenrevolution: theWrittenRevolution
The words are the spark.
Recent Activity
Deviant for 6 Years
Premium Member 'til Hell freezes over:
Given by SRSmith
Statistics 293 Deviations 29,093 Comments 53,852 Pageviews

Random from The Addiction and Expressivity of Life

Random Favourites

Newest Deviations

Webcam

What do you use to keep track of your busy schedule and make sure you don't forget important things and deadlines? 

45%
9 deviants said An old-fashioned yet super reliable agenda/calendar book-thing.
30%
6 deviants said I use ___ , a phone/computer/tablet app. (tell me about it)
25%
5 deviants said My brain. (I've used my brain until now. It's fairly efficient but there are bugs I can't predict)
0%
No deviants said Those are the only three options I can think of so this one counts as "other".

Stamps make me happy.

I even divided these into sections. :dummy:

You Think I Care Stamp by bizarrostamps Rain Stamp by Stamp221 Stamp - I love singing alone by BlueHunter I Heart Purple by webgoddess Stamp: i love blue by flyingdown2011 I Support Silliness Stamp. by miss-strychnine Stamp: Kindness by delusional-dreams I love my TABLET stamp by RRRAI Your Smile... by aternity Violent Stamp by Keiko-Koga :thumb76810001: DA Stamp - Video Games 01 by tppgraphics Hobbit at Heart by eniap .Sleep stamp. by rydi1689 I like trains. by bigfunkychiken

Games:

:thumb39732560: Final Fantasy Stamp by ReverieSummoner I heart HORROR games by RebiValeska Bioshock Stamp by Alcamin Ayane Stamp by neobunny Mortal Kombat stamp by Metadream i love tomb raider games by lucianag GTA: Vice City Stamp by NerdXV MGS Fan Stamp by Busiris monster hunter stamp by Xeno-striker Piggy Stamp by Tippy-The-Bunny Albedo Stamp by Mocha-Rush Xenosaga by IceVallejo Tenchu stamp by Llingy

Movies:

joe black stamp by birdie94 Stamp - Iron Hugs by Isilrina voldemort by lauren-lovebites Monster's Inc. Stamp: ... by XxoOjunefoxOoxX Mulan by ThimbleBostitch The Dark Knight-Joker stamp by Deezmo LOTR - Wander by Jenna-Rose

Anime/Manga/Comics:

Spawn Stamp by MR-PHiLL Witchblade Stamp by Notaku Got Geass? - Lelouch Stamp by DGrayAlchemist Orange-kun by cullencrazay NERV Stamp by HeruNoTenchi Absolute Boyfriend Stamp by BanXiao GITS SAC by skinnyveestamp Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann by Kurasii Lucky Star Dance Stamp... by Sheepio Maria Holic stamp by Nami-DA Imagination stamp by NamiYami One Piece Strawhats Stamp by Zocho Cute Face L + Stamp Death Note by Ludra-Jenova Exalibur Dance Stamp by AlClair Tieria Erde - Stamp by Valandill G00 Fan Stamp by Nawamane Stamp - Gundam SEED: Lacus 2 by Emiliers

Music:

The Original Trio Stamp by nakashimariku Sigur Ros Stamp by Ko-omote Jonsi Stamp by iamadem Explosions in the Sky Stamp by rynald Sara Bareilles Stamp. by mylittlebluesky Classical music stamp by Tollerka Music Stamp by JetProwerTheFox Porcupine Tree stamp by kurokimashin - I Listen To Post-Rock - by AbXorb Film Score Stamp by rushpoint stamp - Fabrizio De Andre' by pallottili Samuel -Subsonica- stamp by HtB-stamps

Visitors



Hello everyone, and welcome to our "tWR Interviews", where we interview experienced writers of our community about the art of writing
If you're reading, please favourite+fav and share the article so we can spread this amazing resource around!

Today we're interviewing doughboycafe, ThornyEnglishRose and LadyLincoln on the characteristics and differences between a standalone story and a chaptered one. And raspil has some knowledge for us too!




If you want to get some more educational reading, here are the other interviews we've released so far:
This interview focuses on chapter VS standalone prose.
What is the difference between an idea that is worthy of standalone and an idea that is worthy of chapters?


raspilTo get the arrogant answer out of the way: I've been doing this long enough to know how many words a story is worth. 

Now here's the regular, human answer: It depends on the potential the idea has. If I write something short and it is well-received, I might find a way to expand on it. But it has to happen organically, I can't force it. Seriously though, you do his long enough, you start to get a feel for what will only work between 2000-3000 words and what is better suited for 50k and up.


doughboycafeI think it has more to do with how long it will take to explore that idea or resolve it. I´ve seen long books with just one idea, short stories with many things going on at once. I feel like often times (though, not ever time) a book will take you start to finish through an issue whereas sometimes a stand-alone only really gives you a snapshot of something. So, if it doesn´t really take that long to explain something or make a point about it, then you´ve got a one shot. If you need more time to delve, it will be chapters.

ThornyEnglishRoseAn idea itself may be suited to both, but then you would approach them in very different ways and get different effects, so perhaps it is purpose rather than premise that determines the better medium. If you want to give your reader a short, sharp message, then a short story is the way to go; if you want to take them on a journey where they can get to know your characters over days and weeks, then give them chapters. Of course, there's no denying that volume of ideas comes into a account. I don't wish to oversimplify, but nor do I wish to overcomplicate. You might for example want to explore a plethora of problems and joys faced by a group of people, like in Alcott's Little Women, or you might want to highlight just one or two aspects of their society, as in her short story 'The Quite Little Woman' (which is set in an orphanage and focuses on the issues therein).

LadyLincolnFor me, the differences are found in the details and one’s expanding story line. If the particular story line involves a great deal of detail – by all means – it certainly merits more chapters. I prefer to be a reader of shorter prose or organized chaptered stories. Ideally, if the general idea the writer is attempting to express cannot be conveyed in under four pages – the story needs to be properly expanded.

Are you a writer of standalone stories or chaptered, longer ones? Is there a reason why?


doughboycafeI do both, but lately I’ve been preferring writing short stand-alones which I never started out doing. I like the way short standalone pieces can have an impact like a sucker punch. I find myself paying closer attention to why every single word is in place with my shorter work (though that is clearly something I ought to apply to my longer work as well :p (Lick)) I still like writing books, because I still enjoy how complicated I can make them and how deep I can get into a problem with them.

ThornyEnglishRoseBoth, because they are both challenging and enjoyable in their own way. Any halfway decent short story I write ends up on DeviantArt, for people to enjoy and for me to get feedback and try to improve. On the other hand, I'm very protective about my novels, and will only post odd chapters here - a compromise between hugging it to my chest until it's perfect, and wanting feedback to help me achieve that perfection (or at least, get it as well written as I possibly can). If I were going to make it in the fierce, competitive world of literature, I'd be a novelist. The reason why is simply that I prefer novels; I just love that long, intimate journey I mentioned in my last answer.

LadyLincolnI do both, but tend to lean towards chaptered, longer ones. My joy comes primarily with novel writing, because I enjoy plot planning, writing dialogue and fleshing out my characters. 

Do you prefer reading one over the other? Is there a reason why?


doughboycafeI prefer reading both, as long as they are well written. I hate reading books that could have been short stand-alones and I hate reading stand alones that don´t have enough meat. But done well, I like both. 

ThornyEnglishRoseChapters, for the reasons I have mentioned, since reading and writing really do go hand-in-hand - no, more than that, for they are in fact in a full and happy marriage. If I like or love a story and its characters, I want to spend a lot of time with them. I do enjoy short stories as well (and couldn't reasonably try to write them if I didn't), but novels are my favourite.

LadyLincolnIt depends solely on the story. If it draws in my interest continually, I will gladly read longer prose – I also enjoy concise, shorter prose and poetry, if done well. Length little matters. Engaging stories are a draw, period. 

What would you recommend a beginner prose writer start with, standalone or chaptered/novel-like prose? Why?


doughboycafeThey are equally challenging to do well. I think stand-alones might be a little easier just because they are less work intensive; you won’t spend weeks writing them start to finish, putting out pages and pages every day. At the very least, you are looking at a smaller word count. And, I do think that outlining is important with both stand-alones and chaptered work, but as the stand-alones will have considerably less outlining involved, they can be good practice for longer, more work intensive projects.

ThornyEnglishRoseStandalone. Whilst I don't wish to imply that they aren't as challenging, or you don't need to work as hard, the sheer fact that they're shorter means you can concentrate your efforts for the best results. One of the challenges is economising with words; beginners trying to write a short story will often find themselves on the path to writing a novella, and not a very good one if it contains the content of a couple of thousand words. You must master making your writing shorter before trying to make it longer!

LadyLincolnI would recommend longer prose and/or novels, because writers have more leeway and freedom to expand their stories. Standalone stories can be quite difficult for some – unless the story idea and focus is tight right off the bat, and directly on point. 

Do you think there's a different approach to writing chaptered and standalone prose, and if so, what's yours?


doughboycafeI think the process is pretty different between the two, but I can’t speak to the differences for any writer but myself. For me, I edit as I go with shorter stand-alone works, because I’m more focused on the actual words than getting from point a to point b. I have a limited amount of time and space to transmit exactly what I want to say. With chaptered works, I tend to write it all, then go back and make 3 or 4 passes at it before I even call it a second draft. I’ll outline first and stick to that, but longer pieces for me are more about getting it done in broad strokes, and then fixing things, because if I revise mid process I have a tendency to get hung up on things and then stall out and not finish.

ThornyEnglishRoseFor me, the basic approach is the same, which is to put into practise what I've learnt: use only the words you need; don't overstate; pace the story well etc. The plot is more voluminous and there are likely to be more characters in a longer piece, which means more planning and more threads to tie together. Such a piece is likely to turn up more errors and inconsistencies than a short story, and personally I have been known to get myself bogged down into some horrendous editing for longer pieces (this may mean that I do need to change my approach to novel writing!). But the writing of any prose, for me, requires the same basic skills and rules of thumb. That's why I recommend starting with short stories before attempting to write a novel.

LadyLincolnNot particularly. To me, it is about properly planning. Without that appropriate planning, organization, and a very clear-cut idea of what direction the shorter story is taking – I feel it is better to stay with a longer prose length to leave freedom for expansion. My own approach to writing either form is a lengthy book of post-its that contain notes for dialogues, future plots, and character summaries. 




Some questions for our readers!



  • Did any of the answers catch you off guard?
  • Did any of the answers particularly connect with you?
  • Are there any questions that you would have answered differently?


A big, big THANK YOU to all who participated in this interview, your contribution was amazing. HeartIf you reader have any questions, tag the deviant you want to ask them to! They knew they were signing up for it. Totally. :shifty:

>>All hail ginkgografix for this beautiful skin.

Donate

TheMaidenInBlack has started a donation pool!
1,042 / 1,000
This is a donation pool for theWrittenRevolution 's Prompts challenges. :heart:

You must be logged in to donate.
  • Anonymous
    Anonymous Deviant
    Donated Jan 4, 2015, 1:05:46 PM
    20
  • :iconiamadem:
    iamadem
    Donated Jan 1, 2015, 12:08:05 AM
    10
  • :icondesenhogiro:
    desenhogiro
    Donated Nov 5, 2014, 12:23:39 PM
    2
  • Anonymous
    Anonymous Deviant
    Donated May 18, 2014, 7:15:54 AM
    100
  • :iconvigilo:
    Vigilo
    Donated May 11, 2014, 11:40:42 PM
    350

deviantID

TheMaidenInBlack
Joseph Louis Gay-Lussac
Your friendly - but a bit of a troll, admittedly - next-door neighbour. I love cookies, gaming, Magic:the Gathering and anime; I love silence, music and nature; I love long walks, being lazy, I love silly things like earrings, jeans and nail polish (and I have tons of them all, beware). I love experimenting with my hair because let's admit it, it always grows back eventually.
I love smiles, cold weather, and I love when my toes are warm next to the fire. I love reading, writing, and improving my English thanks to both of those; I love #thewrittenrevolution and all that it lets me to for the community, I love the happiness it gives me.
I love the friends I have made, and those that I will make tomorrow. I love you.
Interests

Comments


Add a Comment:
 
:iconmotleydreams:
MotleyDreams Featured By Owner 24 minutes ago  Hobbyist Writer
Congrats on the promotion/new role! Thanks for offering to help out the lit community (more than you already do), and if no one thanks you in the months ahead, let me do it now! :heart:

:glomp: You rock.
Reply
:iconsingingflames:
SingingFlames Featured By Owner 1 hour ago  Hobbyist Writer
Welcome to the team! :tighthug:
Reply
:iconginkgografix:
ginkgografix Featured By Owner 1 hour ago
OH LOOK! You have a heart now!
Ok, you had one before as well, but now it's next to your name :eager:

Enjoy the CV times :love:
Reply
:iconlintu47:
lintu47 Featured By Owner 6 hours ago  Hobbyist General Artist
Have fun :heart:
Reply
:icondoughboycafe:
doughboycafe Featured By Owner 7 hours ago  Professional Writer
Look who has a <3. What a coincidence because i <3 you.
Reply
Add a Comment: